Key Colony Homes for Sale

Key Colony Homes for Sale

Welcome to Key Colony Beach, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Monroe County! This picturesque city is renowned for its stunning sunsets, crystal-clear waters, and a laid-back lifestyle that invites you to unwind and embrace island living. With a population of just over 800 residents, Key Colony Beach offers a tight-knit community atmosphere while still providing easy access to the vibrant culture and activities of the surrounding Keys.

Key Colony Beach is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts and water lovers alike. From world-class fishing and diving to kayaking and paddleboarding, the options for adventure are endless. Enjoy the pristine beaches, lush parks, and scenic walking paths that make this area truly special. Plus, with a range of dining options, from casual beachside cafes to fine dining, you’ll never run out of places to savor fresh seafood and local flavors.

For those considering a move, the homes for sale in Key Colony Beach present an incredible opportunity. Whether you’re looking for a charming waterfront cottage, a luxurious beachfront estate, or a cozy condo with stunning views, the real estate market here offers a variety of options to suit any lifestyle. Many properties feature private docks, pools, and expansive outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or simply soaking in the sun.

Discover the charm of Key Colony Beach, where every day feels like a vacation. Embrace the opportunity to own a piece of paradise and experience the unique lifestyle that this enchanting city has to offer!

Newest Key Colony Homes for Sale

$1,235,000
A11686306 MLS
This beautifully remodeled half duplex offers an escape right on the widest canal in Key Colony Beach! Enjoy an electric screened in porch equipped with water misters or relax in your salt water heated or chilled pool. Unobstructed views to a generous 200 ft of canal, you'll have access to both the Ocean and Bay from your finger slip dock with 18,000 LBS boat lift. Inside discover a fully furnished space 2/2 with extra bonus sleeping areas, allowing this property to easily host 8-10 people. Fully remodeled with impact windows/doors for peace of mind. Just a quarter mile from pickleball courts, bocce ball, a playground, and dog park, adding to the convenience of this prime location. An incredible investment opportunity with all necessary rental licenses, street legal golf cart included!

Key Colony
$4,500,000
A11669832 MLS
Discover luxury in this stunning waterfront residence with high-end finishes and concrete block construction for elegance and durability. Enjoy high ceilings, Italian-crafted cabinets, and walk-in closets, complemented by travertine flooring and natural wood in the bedrooms. Property features a circle driveway, single-car garage, and expansive covered terrace, perfect for entertaining. Relax by the modern pool (10x28 ft, 5 ft deep) with a wraparound bench and shallow area for children—ideal for gatherings. Highlights include a propane stove,a 70-foot wooden T dock,a walk-in pantry, and an outdoor BBQ area. Act quickly to choose the final finishes and personalize this spectacular property. Seize this chance to own a luxury home in one of Florida’s most coveted areas! See attached!

230 15th Circle, Key Colony
$2,775,000
A11677822 MLS
Welcome to modern luxury in the heart of the Florida Keys—Key Colony Beach. Exquisitely remodeled coastal contemporary home, open-concept design, perfect for the most discerning buyers. Sitting on a rare, expansive 16,725 sqft lot—twice the size of most in the area— in the most desirable western side of KCB, ample space for multiple cars, trailers, and RVs. Solid CBS stilted construction home surrounded by lush landscaping for privacy. Soaring cathedral ceilings make the 1,775 sq ft, 3-bedroom, 2-bath home feel even more spacious, nesting sliding glass doors and large screened porch blur the line between indoor and outdoor living. 50' concrete dock, complete with 50 Amp power and water. Just two houses from open water and walking distance to Sunset Beach Park. 7-day rentals allowed

181 12th St, Key Colony
$775,000
A11646608 MLS
Motivated to Sell!!! Rare Open Water Views all around. Key Colony Beach Gem! 2/2 Half Duplex. Many upgrades including updated kitchen & baths, Dock, pavers, and open porch. Key Colony Beach is a Private resort community with several restaurants, a 9-hole golf course, a Post office, a police department, and a City Hall. Sunset Park (beach), playground, and tennis courts. Private Cabana Club. Great Rental Opportunity as well. Easy Access to Ocean/Bay. Paradise awaits you! ***Bonus to Buyers: 5 days and 4 nights Certificate for Luxury Vacation Resort Only in Cabo San Lucas***

33 Sadowski Cswy, Key Colony
$525,000
A11639184 MLS
Seller Incentive: The seller is offering a 1-year rate buy-down! New co-ownership opportunity: Own one-eighth of this professionally managed, turnkey home by Pacaso. Blue skies and waterways await at Sunset Park. This Key Colony Beach retreat offers access to the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic. Less than an hour from Key West airport, this gated community is perfect for a serene family getaway. Enjoy included bikes, nearby Pickleball and Tennis courts, and an outdoor kitchen with a pool and patio. The gourmet kitchen features Thermador appliances. The upstairs family room has a wet bar and canal views. Four additional bedrooms complete the home.

220 14th St Unit 3, Key Colony
$525,000
A11639164 MLS
New co-ownership opportunity: Own one-eighth of this professionally managed, turnkey home by Pacaso. Blue skies and waterways await at Sunset Park. This Key Colony Beach retreat offers access to the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic. Less than an hour from Key West airport, this gated community is perfect for a serene family getaway. Enjoy included bikes, nearby Pickleball and Tennis courts, and an outdoor kitchen with a pool and patio. The gourmet kitchen features Thermador appliances. The upstairs family room has a wet bar and canal views. Four additional bedrooms complete the home.

220 14th St Unit 1, Key Colony
$14,999,000
A11624172 MLS
Nestled along the sun-kissed shores of 15th Circle on Key Colony Beach is the iconic Lighthouse. This expansive and recently updated home offers the epitome of luxury coastal living. With its private beachfront, you'll wake up to the gentle lull of the waves and breathtaking views. Generously sized living spaces designed for comfort and coastal elegance encapsulating the tranquil Atlantic Ocean. Upgraded kitchen perfect for culinary enthusiasts and entertainers alike. 9 bedrooms, each offering serene views and natural light. The Owner's wing for unparalleled privacy, complete with a walk-in closet, steam shower, tub, double vanity, wet bar, Pilates and music studio, beautiful home office and so much more. Experience the allure of Florida living in this luxurious waterfront haven.

195 15th Cir, Key Colony
Start Your Search